FPCE says the objectives of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act remain far from being achieved even after nearly a decade, calls for stronger implementation and greater protection for homebuyers.
By The Realty Times | Real Estate News Services
NEW DELHI : The Forum for People’s Collective Efforts
(FPCE), a national organisation representing homebuyers and one of the key
campaigners behind the enactment of the Real Estate (Regulation and
Development) Act (RERA), has raised concerns over the implementation of the
landmark legislation in India.
In a letter dated October 26 to Prime Minister Narendra
Modi, the organisation stated that the objectives of RERA were “far from being
achieved” even after nearly 10 years. The representation highlights the
continuing difficulties faced by homebuyers and raises questions about the
effectiveness of regulatory mechanisms established under the law.
Concerns Over Regulatory Gaps and Homebuyer Protection
According to FPCE, although RERA has brought a large number
of real estate projects under a registration framework and introduced important
disclosure requirements, several problems continue to affect buyers across the
country.
The organisation has pointed to persistent issues such as:
- Delays
in project completion and possession.
- Diversion
or misuse of funds collected from homebuyers.
- One-sided
builder-buyer agreements.
- Inadequate
scrutiny of documents during project registration.
- Delays
in implementing refund and compensation orders passed by RERA authorities.
- Weak
accountability and enforcement mechanisms.
FPCE has argued that merely registering projects and
requiring developers to disclose information cannot be considered sufficient
evidence of the law's success. The real test should be whether homebuyers
receive timely possession, financial protection and effective legal remedies
when developers fail to meet their commitments.
FPCE Seeks Separation of Real Estate Promotion and
Consumer Protection
One of the major concerns raised by FPCE is the perceived
conflict between promoting the real estate industry and protecting homebuyers.
Currently, the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs (MoHUA)
oversees the policy framework relating to the real estate sector. FPCE believes
that the responsibility for protecting homebuyers should be separated from the
responsibility of promoting real estate development.
The organisation has proposed that MoHUA continue to focus
on the growth and development of the real estate sector, while the Department
of Consumer Affairs should take exclusive responsibility for homebuyer
protection.
According to the forum, placing consumer protection under a
department whose primary responsibility is safeguarding consumer interests
could help strengthen regulatory independence, accountability and grievance
redressal.
A National Appellate Tribunal Also Proposed
FPCE has also called for the establishment of a National
Appellate Tribunal for real estate matters. At present, homebuyers generally
have to approach state-level real estate appellate tribunals when challenging
RERA authority decisions.
The organisation believes that a national-level appellate
institution could bring greater consistency to the interpretation of RERA
provisions across different states. It could also help reduce differences in
regulatory approaches and strengthen the overall dispute-resolution framework.
Other suggestions include making agreements for sale legally
binding in a stronger statutory form and introducing provisions allowing
homebuyers to exit property transactions under exceptional circumstances, such
as the loss of employment or the death of an earning family member.
Government Response and the Road Ahead
The issue has also received attention from the Cabinet
Secretariat. Following the October 26 letter, Cabinet Secretary T. V.
Somanathan responded on November 2, thanking FPCE for its suggestions and
stating that they would be examined.
A delegation of FPCE representatives subsequently met
Cabinet Secretariat officials on November 12 to explain its proposals and
discuss the need for structural changes in the regulatory framework.
₹12.44 Lakh Crore Trapped in Delayed Projects
Highlighting the financial impact of delayed housing
projects, FPCE has estimated that approximately ₹12.44 lakh crore of
homebuyers' money is trapped in delayed real estate projects across India,
affecting around 27.6 lakh families.
According to the organisation, this estimate is based on its
analysis of data from the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs. The forum has
warned that the problem extends beyond individual homebuyers, affecting
household savings, financial institutions, consumer spending, employment and
confidence in the real estate sector.
What It Means for India's Real Estate Industry
The concerns raised by FPCE have renewed the debate over the
effectiveness of RERA and the need for further reforms in India's property
market.
For developers, stronger regulatory enforcement could mean
greater scrutiny of project documentation, financial disclosures, construction
timelines and contractual commitments. While these measures may increase
compliance responsibilities, they could also help improve transparency and
build buyer confidence.
For homebuyers, the effectiveness of RERA should ultimately
be reflected in timely possession, protection of invested money and speedy
resolution of disputes.
Nearly a decade after the introduction of RERA, the
challenge is no longer simply to bring developers and projects under a
regulatory framework. It is to ensure that the rights promised under the
legislation are effectively protected.
Whether the Centre accepts FPCE's recommendations and
introduces structural reforms could become an important factor in shaping the
next phase of India's real estate regulatory framework.

0 Comments